Editing, Writing Tips

Top 5 Tips for Selecting an Editor

Happy Black Friday, everyone! I hope all of you who celebrate Thanksgiving had a wonderful, family and food-filled Turkey Day! NaNoWriMo is coming to a close, which means the next step for all of the participants is  lots and lots of editing. Now, I know we all have various feelings about this stop in our writing journeys. Being a freelance editor myself, I happen to love this phase, but I also know how hard it can be to find just the right person to help you along. Therefore, I present to you my top five tips for selecting your perfect editor.

  1. Do your research 

Every editor is different. Some specialize in certain genres or are experts at one particular type of editing, some have more experience working in academics than fiction, and everyone has a different price point and method. One might prefer to work with PDFs while another might use track changes on Word, and a third might opt for only writing an editorial letter rather than commenting on the manuscript itself. Make sure you know what you’re getting so that you’re not spending your hard-earned money on a service that you don’t want. Look at their websites, read testimonials, and if you have a question you can’t find the answer to, contact them using Twitter, Facebook, etc. And speaking of social media:

2. Get to know your editor

Keep in mind that you’re going to be working with this person for a period of weeks or months to help improve your manuscript. If you couldn’t tolerate being a work colleague in a brick and mortar with someone, they’re probably not going to be the best person to help you. A website is a great place to start, but also follow them on social media if you can. See what kind of content they post. Are they supportive and encouraging to the writing community? Do they blog a lot? If so, what about? Maybe they’re authors, and they’re discussing their own writing journey. That could be a good indicator if you want someone who has been through all this before. Or maybe they have a brood of children they love to travel with. Someone like that might be able to offer extra authenticity if you’re writing a book set somewhere other than where you live, or if you have a lot of young characters in your novel(s). These insights will give you a more complete picture of who they are as a person, as well as shed some light on ways they could specifically help you

3. Be ready to receive criticism

To get the most out of this experience, you need to develop a thick skin. To do that, you should have a general understanding of the kind of feedback your manuscript is going to receive. That way, you can put aside your personal feelings and look at each new round of edits as a means of improvement. Finding beta readers should generally always happen before you submit your manuscript to editors to ensure it is the strongest it can be, but receiving their feedback is also a great opportunity to practice this skill. The further you go in the editing process, the harsher your critiques are going to get, simply because, the better your book becomes, the more editors want to make it shine.

4. Don’t send first drafts

Terry Pratchett said, “The first draft is just you telling yourself the story.” After you finish your book you should, of course, celebrate! Congratulations! You just did something really, really, really, hard! Pop open a bottle of bubbly and show it off! Do not, however, send your manuscript to your editor seconds, hours, or even days after writing “The End.” Why? Because 99.9% of the time, whether you outlined like crazy or just wrote by the seat of your pants, the book you have in front of you will be different than the one you imagined in your head. That means there will be plot holes, incomplete character arcs, and a plethora of other issues. And that’s okay. Things like that should be there, because you’ve just told the story for the first time. Remember, this draft isn’t meant for other readers, it’s meant for you. So, congratulate yourself, take some time off, and then see how the manuscript looks once you feel refreshed and ready to create again. If you go back and read your story three weeks later and don’t see anything that needs improvement then… Well, either you’re a genius, or you’re still too close.

Only after several rounds of self-edits and betas, when you feel your story is the strongest it can be, should you start sending it out. Editors are not looking for perfection, (if we were, we’d be out of a job), but we also don’t want manuscripts that look like the author hit send too soon. If there are so many unfinished plot threads that the reader is left with 20 questions and no answers, or if the main character is Riley, then Heather, then Gabriella in the same manuscript, those are easily fixable mistakes. A good editor will still work with you, but it will likely cost you both more time, energy, and money, and the improvement of your work will be slower going.

5. Editing is subjective 

You should always consider the editorial feedback you are given. After all, you paid for it and the editor worked hard to give you your money’s worth. Always remember though, that you are the author. If the editor read something differently than the majority of your audience, or they gave you a suggestion that doesn’t mesh with your goals or intentions for the book, you don’t have to use it. Personally, though, I recommend going by the “rule of three.” If three editors, or betas, or critique partners say that your villain needs a stronger motivation, or want the answer to a question by the end of book one rather than the beginning of book two, it’s probably a good indication that they aren’t the only ones who will feel that way, and you should at least brainstorm how to incorporate the critique.

Bonus Announcement: In honor of Black Friday, I’m hosting a giveaway where three lucky winners will receive an editing service of their choice for FREE. Click HERE for more information.

As always, keep making magic, word weavers!

42917 Signature

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s